麻豆原创

The Snowman: Nordic Noir With a Hint of Dirty Harry

The Snowman movie clip

Tomas Alfredson鈥檚 recently released film adaptation of Jo Nesb酶鈥檚 bestselling novel The Snowman closely captures, in its slow, quiet intensity, the bleak essence of Nordic Noir.

This article was originally published at by Alec Charles,聽Dean of Faculty of Arts, University of Winchester. It is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

The origins of Nordic Noir

The tones of Nordic Noir originate in the region鈥檚 uncompromising climates and landscapes and build upon the cold cultural comforts of Kierkegaard, Bergman and Munch.

Its international popularity as a literary and screen genre has led to various attempts to adapt its most successful narratives for English-language audiences, including Hollywood versions of The Killing and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and British reinventions of The Bridge (as The Tunnel) and Wallander.

But, despite some lukewarm , Alfredson鈥檚 film appears rather more successful than those other English-language attempts at the genre in its faithfulness to the cold heart of its genre.

Harry Hole on-screen

The ice-cool Michael Fassbender seems born for the role of Nesb酶鈥檚 inscrutable and taciturn Harry Hole in Alfredson鈥檚 adaptation.

His understated performance recalls the character鈥檚 origins in Clint Eastwood鈥檚 Harry Callahan and in Humphrey Bogart鈥檚 deadpan hard men of 1940s film noir.

Michael Fassbender in The Snowman
Michael Fassbender in The Snowman. Universal Pictures.

Yet the film鈥檚 machismo perhaps sites it closer to Dirty Harry and the traditions of American noir than to the genre into which the Nordic variety has more recently evolved.

Since Kurt Wallander鈥檚 daughter Linda took the lead in Henning Mankell鈥檚 2005 novel Before the Frost, and (that same year) first revealed her dragon tattoo, the genre has become increasingly characterised by its strong female protagonists.

A far cry from the lazy chauvinism of Harry Callahan or Sam Spade, this Scandinavian genre has, at its best, explored the conflicted heroism of the likes of Sarah Lund, Saga Nor茅n, Thora Gudmundsdottir and Eva Th枚rnblad.

The growing (if only partial and belated) centricity of female characters to such popular narratives is not uniquely Scandinavian.

As such screen stars as , and take the reins of major popular genre franchises, might the brooding masculinity of Fassbender here come to seem somewhat retrograde?

The team parachuted onto snow covered ground

Alterations from the novel

Alfredson鈥檚 film, while remarkably faithful to the tone of the novel, differs from Nesb酶鈥檚 original in a number of aspects 鈥� not least the deaths of two main characters who survive the book (albeit hardly unscathed).

These deaths take place for the sake of narrative impact and closure within the two-hour feature film.

But this haste to resolution feels out of kilter with Alfredson鈥檚 commitment to a genre which, at its most effective, produced a 20-hour exploration of grief and pain in The Killing鈥檚 first season 鈥� and Nesb酶鈥檚 own ongoing, multi-novel elaborations upon the consequences of acts of extreme violence.

The strategy that it is easier to kill off characters than to come to terms with issues of emotional complexity aligns the film itself rather too closely with the mentality of its own serial killer.

Milan Kundera, by contrast, once advocated the virtues of slowness in an increasingly impatient contemporary culture.

Set apart from the mainstream

It is this capacity for quiet contemplation which has set Netflix and Nordic Noir apart from the puerile content of YouTube and the premature climaxes of so much of Hollywood鈥檚 macho product.

Snowman Christmas scene

Alfredson鈥檚 film opens with the brutalisation, breakdown and suicide of a victim of domestic violence played by the Swedish actor .

Helin is one of the matriarchs of small screen Nordic Noir (along with The Killing and Fortitude鈥檚 ), best known for her portrayal of Saga Nor茅n in The Bridge.

One might therefore read this opening as a declaration of the film鈥檚 departure from Nordic Noir鈥檚 recent female-centred history.

But it doesn鈥檛 so much move on from the genre鈥檚 focus on gender relations as it offers its own dark perspective on that subject.

The film鈥檚 core message is that the blame for the sins of the fathers tends to be visited by their sons upon their mothers and mother figures.

It explores how male violence against women perpetuates itself by blaming women for that cycle of violence 鈥� and its final explicit message is that it is (of course) not the women but the men who are to blame.

Stortinget, the Norwegian Parliament, in Oslo
The Parliament building in Oslo, Norway

No typical hero

Key to this message are the parallels which the film draws between its villains (its emotionally distant cigarette smoker of a serial killer and his abusive policeman father) and its protagonist, the neglectful father and chain-smoking detective Harry Hole.

The laconic Harry Hole is no typical hero. He is, as his name suggests, something of a nothing, an emotional vacuum. (His name may also contain an implied expletive: there is something of the hole about Harry.)

Like Gary Oldman鈥檚 George Smiley in Alfredson鈥檚 2011 adaptation of 鈥� and, like Saga Nor茅n, Sarah Lund and Lisbeth Salander for that matter 鈥� he fails in his personal, social and professional relationships.

His main contribution to the film鈥檚 actual action is to get wounded and fall over. He is a drunkard who 鈥� in Nesb酶鈥檚 鈥� skids further and further off the rails and eventually turns to opium abuse.

A view of Oslo from Ekeberg
Oslo

He is, as he admits in the film鈥檚 dramatic and emotional climax, fundamentally selfish. In short, he is no kind of a role model for his adopted son or for a contemporary audience. His one redeeming feature 鈥� and the film鈥檚 鈥� is that he knows it.

That is perhaps scant consolation; but in a film released as a series of shattering revelations emerged about sexual misconduct of some of Hollywood鈥檚 biggest players, its overt polemic against such bludgeoning misogyny might seem almost as timely as the blockbusting returns of such kick-ass heroines as Lara Croft and Wonder Woman.

If Harry Hole, then, is a hero for our times, then it is only because (unlike Eastwood鈥檚 glamorously dirty cop) this emphatically unwholesome Harry is one whose conduct serves not as a model but as a warning.

This article was originally published at by Alec Charles,聽Dean of Faculty of Arts, University of Winchester. It is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

About The Conversation

This article is republished with permission from our friends at The Conversation, an independent source of news and views, sourced from the academic and research community and delivered direct to the public.

Norway Weekly Subscribe Banner

Leave a Comment